Are the Dubai Penguins Ambassadors of the Wild, or Agents of Profit?

Candice Gaukel Andrews by Candice Gaukel Andrews | June 18th, 2012 | 2 Comments
topic: Eco Travel, Green Living

Penguin in Antarctica

In the hot, desert climate of Dubai on the Arabian Peninsula, 20 penguins are living in comfort, say the managers of Ski Dubai, the first indoor ski resort in the Middle East. The birds reside in a climate-controlled environment, receive the best veterinary care, and never have to worry about lurking predators.

When you visit Ski Dubai, you can pay to have a “penguin encounter,” where you’ll be able to play with and touch the penguins. Representatives of the resort say that these animals are “ambassadors,” teaching patrons about their wild counterparts and the need to conserve their threatened natural habitat, Antarctica.

But can animals that have been born and raised in captivity and habituated to humans in unnatural ways ever be true ambassadors for the natural world? Can they teach us anything about the wild or move us to care for the environments from which they are so distantly removed?

A worry-free life

King penguins

King penguins live on sub-Antarctic islands dotted around the continent, where they form huge colonies on slopes with nearby beaches for access to the sea. ©Colin McNulty

The Dubai penguins were relocated earlier this year from SeaWorld in San Antonio, Texas, where a penguin-breeding program has been underway for several years. Of the 20, 10 are king penguins, currently listed as of “least concern” on the International Union for Conservation of Nature Red List of Threatened Species. The other 10 are gentoo penguins, officially listed as “near threatened.” Ski Dubai has stated that the birds “are treated like royalty,” and that their presence helps raise public awareness about the importance of conserving these species.

In fact, the penguins do seem to be well cared for. Ski Dubai has fabricated a snow-covered “world” for them that is chilled to a constant 28 to 30 degrees Fahrenheit, a habitat the managers describe as “mirroring Antarctica.” Ski Dubai reports that a staff of 13 people serves the penguins restaurant-quality dishes and that veterinarians check the birds every two weeks. According to the resort, the penguins are never forced to do anything they don’t want to do and are under no stress.

Ski Dubai says that some of the money it makes from the penguin encounters will be put toward penguin conservation efforts and that the birds themselves will help raise awareness of the importance of protecting their wild counterparts. The resort is counting on this attraction to be a popular — and profitable — endeavor, since close-up, “quality” time with penguins is a hard-to-come-by experience in the Middle East. The hope is that once a person spends time with the birds, he or she will feel an affinity for the species and will want to aid in saving its natural environment.

Growing concern

Using captive animals as ambassadors for conservation efforts is not a new idea, of course. Many animal rehabilitation centers in the United States use injured animals that — for one reason or another — cannot be returned to the wild as “animal educators.” These animals are taken to exhibits and shows to interest the public in the plight of the species as a whole.

bald eagle

This injured eagle became an “educator” for The Raptor Center at the University of Minnesota. ©John T. Andrews

The Dubai penguins, however, have a different history than born-in-the-wild animals that are rescued after an injury and are too impaired to survive on their own back in their natural habitats. The Dubai penguins were bred and raised domestically and now must live out their lives artificially, far from their native home.

Critics say that Ski Dubai is a profit-seeking venture, and that if the company were genuinely concerned about protecting penguins and other Antarctic creatures, it would simply leave them be. Much like the operations that breed and keep tigers in captivity in order to provide photography enthusiasts with opportunities to take pictures of big cats or school sports teams with mascots, Ski Dubai is simply profiting off the trade in wildlife and keeping what-should-be-wild animals as “pets.”

Do you think the Dubai penguins are true animal ambassadors, educating people about their species and the fragile Antarctic ecosystem — just as injured wildlife from rehabilitation centers do? Or are the healthy, born-in-captivity Dubai penguins purely agents for human entertainment and profit?

Happy trails,

Candy

Feature photo: Will the captive Dubai penguins generate public interest in the wild gentoos and their natural home in Antarctica? ©Colin McNulty


TravelerVoice

Comments

  1. I haven’t visited the penguins in Ski Dubai but have visited the penguins at the Dubai Aquarium in the Dubai Mall. Was disturbed by what I perceived to be a rather bleak existence in a small indoor enclosure at the rear of the area. Did you check them out? It just didn’t feel right.

    Perhaps if they are breed in captivity then that is their natural habitat even though they are relatives of those born in the wild. But their “captive” habitats should be big enough and replicate the natural habitat. I still question the right to take away their purpose in life by treating them as royalty and doing everything for them.

    Katie Foster | June 19th, 2012 | Comment Permalink
  2. “Their purpose in life”… as food for seals and polar bears? These particular penguins have no survival skills and would be doomed.

    Kathy Heaton | June 25th, 2012 | Comment Permalink

Post a Comment

If you want to show your picture with your comment, go get a gravatar!